Last reviewed: October 2026
If a supplier has been shipping every 90 days whether you needed it or not, you are not alone. Auto-refill programs ship on the plan's schedule, not on how many sensors or strips you actually used. Test less often, skip a few sensor changes while traveling, switch from strips to a CGM, or change a dose, and within a year the closet holds more than you will use before the dates run out. Those sealed boxes are worth money, and the sooner they are sold the more they bring.
Why the pile grows
- Quantity limits are set by the plan, not by you. A prescription for testing four times a day ships 100-count boxes on that assumption even if you test twice.
- CGM switches leave strips behind. Moving to Dexcom or Libre drops strip use to almost nothing, but the strip auto-refill keeps going until someone cancels it.
- Device upgrades strand the old generation. DASH to OmniPod 5, Libre 2 to Libre 3. The last shipment of the old system usually arrives after you switched. Our guide on switching CGMs or pumps covers that.
- Insurance changes restart the cycle with a new supplier and a new formulary, as explained in changed insurance? what to do with leftover supplies.
Turn the tap off first
Call the mail-order supplier and ask them to pause or cancel the auto-refill, or move it to "ship on request." Then ask your prescriber to adjust the quantity to what you use. Nothing on this page helps if the next shipment is already on a truck. Suppliers will not take back the shipments they already sent, which is the subject of do pharmacies buy back unused test strips?
Which boxes you can sell
Sealed, unexpired boxes with at least 3 months of dating that were paid for by you or by a private or employer plan. That covers most working-age people with a commercial plan. The catch is Medicare: a large share of mail-order diabetic supply is billed to Medicare Part B, and supplies paid for by Medicare, Medicaid, or the VA cannot be resold by anyone. Check the box for a "For Medicare use only" stamp or a DME label with a Medicare billing reference. If you are unsure, send a photo of the label and we will tell you. The full rule is in is it legal to sell diabetic supplies?
Sell the extras, keep what you use
Sort the closet by expiration date. Keep the boxes you will use before they expire, working from the oldest date forward, and sell the rest now. Dating is the biggest factor in the offer inside a product tier, so a box sold with a year left is worth considerably more than the same box sold with four months left. The tiers themselves are in how much are diabetic supplies worth?
How selling works
- Text or submit the product, count, and dates. Photos help; here is what to shoot.
- A person replies with a number, usually within a couple of hours, and tells you up front if any box does not qualify.
- Pickup within about 100 miles of Charlotte depending on the offer, an appointment at our Charlotte office, or a free prepaid label from anywhere in the US.
- Paid by Zelle, Venmo, or cash the day the boxes are inspected. Twenty or more boxes is a bulk lot with bulk pricing.
Common questions
Can I send auto-shipped supplies back to the mail-order pharmacy?
No. Suppliers can stop future shipments but do not take back the ones already delivered. Call them to pause the auto-refill, then sell the sealed extras.
My supplies are shipped through Medicare. Can I sell the extras?
No. Supplies paid for by Medicare, Medicaid, or the VA cannot be resold by anyone. Boxes from a private or employer plan, or bought retail, can be.
How do I know which boxes to keep and which to sell?
Sort by expiration date, keep what you will use before the dates run out starting with the oldest, and sell the rest now while the dating is long.
Does the plan's DME label stop me from selling?
A DME label from a private plan does not prohibit a sale; those boxes are quoted case by case. A Medicare or Medicaid billing label does prohibit it.
How many extra boxes do people usually have?
Anywhere from a couple to a closet. Twenty or more boxes counts as a bulk lot and gets bulk pricing and priority pickup.
Text or submit your supplies and a person replies with a cash offer, usually within a couple of hours.
Get a Quote