Last updated: November 11, 2026

The short answer

A trustworthy buyer gives you a written per-box offer before you ship, has a real address and a phone a person answers, never asks you for money, and tells you in advance what happens if a box does not pass inspection. If any one of those is missing, slow down.

Nine warning signs

  1. A price far above everyone else's. The quote exists to get your boxes in the mail. The real number comes after they arrive.
  2. No offer until after you ship. "Send it in and we will evaluate" means you have given up all your leverage.
  3. No return policy for rejected boxes. If you cannot get your supplies back when you turn down a lower offer, the lower offer is not really optional.
  4. No address, or only a P.O. box, and no business name. You should be able to find who you are dealing with.
  5. Payment by gift card, crypto, or a check for more than the agreed amount. An overpayment followed by "send back the difference" is a classic fake-check scheme.
  6. Any fee. Registration, inspection, insurance, "label activation." Buyers pay sellers, not the other way around.
  7. Pressure. "This price expires in an hour" is a tactic. Real offers do track expiration dates, but not by the hour.
  8. No questions about where the supplies came from. A buyer who will take Medicare, Medicaid, or VA boxes, or opened and expired ones, is not following the rules, and that tells you how they will treat you.
  9. Reviews only on the buyer's own website. Look for reviews on Google or another platform the buyer cannot edit.

Five checks that take five minutes

Meeting a local buyer safely

Selling in person removes the shipping risk, and it has its own common-sense rules. Meet at a place you choose, such as a public spot, your workplace, or the buyer's business address. Count the payment before you hand over the boxes. Do not accept a personal check from someone you have not dealt with before. A local buyer should inspect the boxes in front of you and pay on the spot.

Scams aimed at sellers on social media

Many reports start with a message from a stranger on Facebook or a neighborhood app offering to buy test strips. The offer is high, the buyer wants you to ship first to a residential address, and the payment either never arrives or is reversed. If you ship first to a stranger, no payment method will get your boxes back. Our guide to selling on Facebook Marketplace, eBay, or Craigslist goes through each platform.

What a legitimate transaction looks like with us

We are a Charlotte business with a published address, 900 Pressley Rd, Charlotte, NC 28217, open by appointment, and our reviews are on Google. More detail is on is Cash For Diabetic Supplies NC legit?

If something has already gone wrong

Save every message, the tracking number, and photos of what you sent. Ask the buyer in writing for the reason and for the return of your boxes. If you were paid by a check that looks wrong, do not send any money back. Report fraud to the Federal Trade Commission at ReportFraud.ftc.gov and to your state attorney general's consumer protection office.

Common questions

The bait and switch. A buyer quotes a high price to get you to ship, then pays much less after the box arrives, claiming damage or short dating. Protect yourself by sending photos first, getting the per-box offer in writing, and asking what happens to your boxes if you reject a revised offer.

It can be, if the buyer has a real business name, a published address, a phone number a person answers, reviews on a platform the buyer does not control, and a written offer before you ship.

No. A legitimate buyer never asks you to pay a registration fee, an inspection fee, or an insurance fee, and never asks you to send money back out of a payment.

Ask for the reason in writing with photos of the problem, and ask for your boxes back if you do not agree. Keep your tracking number and all messages. If the buyer will not respond, report it to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov and to your state attorney general.

We quote from your description or photos before anything is shipped or picked up. The quote you accept is what you get paid when the boxes are as described. If a box does not match, we tell you why, and non-qualifying mail-in items are shipped back free on request.

Get my free quote →